AES Europe 2025

This paper investigates the subjective evaluation of two prominent three-dimensional spatialization techniques—Vector Base Amplitude Panning (VBAP) and High-Order Ambisonics (HOA)—using IRCAM’s Spat in an immersive concert setting. The listening test was conducted in the New Hall at the Royal Danish Academy of Music, which features a 44-speaker immersive audio system. The musical stimuli included electronic compositions and modern orchestral recordings, providing a diverse range of temporal and spectral content. The participants comprised experienced Tonmeisters and non-experienced musicians, who were seated in off-center positions to simulate real-world audience conditions. This study provides an ecologically valid subjective evaluation methodology.
The results indicated that VBAP excelled in spatial clarity and sound quality, while HOA demonstrated superior envelopment. The perceptual differences between the two techniques were relatively minor, influenced by room acoustics and suboptimal listening positions. Furthermore, music genre had no significant impact on the evaluation outcomes.
The study highlights VBAP’s strength in precise localization and HOA's capability for creating immersive soundscapes, aiming to bridge the gap between ideal and real-world applications in immersive sound reproduction and perception. The findings suggest the need to balance trade-offs when selecting spatialization techniques for specific purposes, venues, and audience positions. Future research will focus on evaluating a wider range of spatialization methods in concert environments and optimizing them to improve the auditory experience for distributed audiences.